Character-related factors
Typeface
The following factors are of particular importance for the selection of suitable typefaces for people with visual impairments:1
Recognizability
Recognizability is understood as the property of individual characters that enables them to be identified and distinguished from others2 .
In order for letters to be recognized, they must first be learned. Their form follows established conventions in each case. The fact that these three letters designate the same consonant is not formally comprehensible and can only be identified by knowledgeable readers.
Discernibility
The discernibility of individual letter forms facilitates the quick grasp of their meaning.
While Geometric Sans-Serifs, which follow a geometric form principle, often have very similar letter forms (top), characters of Humanist Sans-Serifs, which follow a dynamic form principle, differ more clearly from each other (bottom).
Confusable character forms can also be found at 1, I and l .
Aperture
The size of the apertures of character shapes strengthens their distinguishability in poor print quality, blurred vision, halation, or poor lighting conditions, which is especially evident with the lower-case letters a, c, e, o, or s.
The blur simulation shows that characters with small apertures, typical to the static form principle of the Neo-Grotesque (top: Arial) are less distinguishable from each other than characters with large apertures, typical to the dynamic form principle of the Humanist Sans-Serif, (bottom: Neue Frutiger 1450).
Stroke contrast
High contrasts between stem and hairline, as exhibited in particular by Didone typefaces (Modern Face), lead to fine lines breaking away or no longer being perceived at small sizes, in the case of halation, poor print quality, weak background contrast or low screen resolution. Garalde (Old Style) and sans serif typefaces generally have lower stroke contrasts than other typefaces and are therefore more suitable for readers with impaired vision.
Stroke contrasts vary greatly depending on the form principle of each group as can be seen in this simplified illustration. While Didone typefaces often have very fine hairlines, Garalde typefaces have stronger hairlines, also the horizontal curves as in h, m, n and u as well as in b, d, p and q are much thicker. The Transitional is an intermediate form between the two. The Sans Serif (Lineale) usually has a lower contrast between stems and hairlines. However, the individual typefaces within the classification group are subject to a wide variety of forms, which is why classification systems of typefaces offer only a rough orientation.
Typeface
form principle
form principle
form principle
(Grotesk)
(e.g. Futura)
(e.g. Helvetica)
(e.g. The Sans)
(Antiqua)
(e.g. Lubalin Graph)
(e.g. Bodoni)
(e.g. Garamond)

This simplified overview of the different form principles3 of typefaces with and without serifs shows that sans-serifs, which follow the dynamic form principle, have better distinguishable and more open letter forms with lower stroke contrast than other typefaces. Typefaces of this form principle are especially recommended for signage text, due to situational influences on the reading conditions placing a high demand on legibility.4
Since people with visual impairments generally have higher legibility requirements, these readers favour Humanist Sans-Serifs for all text types.
The typeface samples shown below are examples of typefaces of this form principle.
Typefaces delivered with operating systems or software (not separately chargeable)
Open source typefaces (free of charge according to the terms of use)
Licensed typefaces (fee required)
Summarized Recommendations
Typeface
- Humanist Sans-Serifs are recommended for readers with visual impairments.
- Neo-Grotesque typefaces, such as Arial or Helvetica, are less suitable than Humanist Sans-Serifs due to their more closed letterforms with smaller apertures.
- When using serif typefaces, typefaces that follow the dynamic form principle (Garalde) are preferable.
- Didone typefaces are not suitable due to their fine hairlines.
- Serifs should not touch.
- Ligatures (combination of two letters in one character) sometimes make it difficult to recognize individual characters and should therefore be used with care. Characters may only join under the condition that the individual characters are easily discernable.
Footnotes
-
↑
DIN 1450
Lettering – Legibility
November 2024 edition
Jan Filek
Read/ability – Typografie und Lesbarkeit
Niggli 2013
Ralf Herrmann
TypoJournal 2, 2010
www.typografie.info -
↑
DIN 1450
Lettering – Legibility
November 2024 edition -
↑
Indra Kupferschmid
Buchstaben kommen selten allein
Niggli 2001
Hans Peter Willberg
Wegweiser Schrift
Verlag Hermann Schmidt Mainz 2001 -
↑
DIN 1450
Schriften – Leserlichkeit
November 2024 edition
Ralf Herrmann
TypoJournal 2, 2010
www.typografie.info
Florian Adler, Sven Neumann
Leserlichkeit von Schrift im Öffentlichen Raum
in: J. Eckert, C. Fischer, I. Pfeiffer, P. Schäfer, A. Uebele u. a. (Hg.)
Schrift und Identität, Niggli 2013